The Caribbean, Bahamas and Central America
From the British Virgin Islands to the reefs off Belize, this stretch of the Atlantic has some of the shortest flights from the US to a real private island, and some of the widest range in what one costs. We rank the true single-resort islands of the Caribbean, the Bahamas, and Central America's coasts: how many villas, how private the beach really is, what the transfer from the nearest airport costs and how long it takes, and whether the island still feels like an escape once the boat leaves. Overwater villas and all-inclusive packages belong to our sister sites.
- 1
An 850-acre private island in the British Virgin Islands limited to 35 guests maximum in 18 rooms, with seven beaches and 90 percent untouched wilderness.
- 2
A 1,800-acre private island in the British Virgin Islands with 52 oceanfront rooms and villas, featuring five secluded beaches and direct ferry access from Tortola.
- 3
A 14-island private archipelago resort in Panama's Gulf of Chiriquí with six casitas accommodating 2-8 guests each. Maximum 28 guests total, near UNESCO-protected Coiba National Park, with conservation-focused operations.
- 4
A 4-acre private island off San Pedro, Belize, with seven individually bookable villas and one of the highest staff-to-guest ratios in the Caribbean. Each villa has a private dock, plunge pool, and dedicated butler service.
- 5
A 1,000-acre private island in Turks and Caicos with a mile-long beach, accessible by 35-minute boat transfer from Providenciales. The island accommodates around 130 guests maximum across rooms, suites, houses, and privately owned estates.
- 6
A 300-acre private island resort two miles off Antigua with 28 rooms, 14 villas, and access via a 10-minute catamaran, part of the Oetker Collection.
- 7
A 96-acre barefoot-chic island off Andros with 21 rooms spread across cottages, bungalows, and Balinese-style beach houses, accessible only by private ferry or seaplane. The island stretches nearly three miles along white sand beaches.
- 8
A 1,100-acre all-inclusive private island resort in southeast Turks and Caicos with 29 bungalows and 11 villas. Reached by 20-minute flight from Providenciales, or via new American Airlines service through South Caicos.
- 9
Six private oceanfront villas spread across a 50-acre island in the Exumas, each with its own 17-foot powerboat and exclusive beach. Accessible from Nassau or Fort Lauderdale by small aircraft to Staniel Cay airstrip.
- 10
A 16-acre adults-only resort in southern Belize with 20 private cabanas, maximum 44 guests, and direct boat access from the Dangriga airstrip. The island operates as a self-contained destination with overwater villas and beach cabanas.
- 11
An 800-acre private island in Turks and Caicos, less than a mile wide and two miles long, home to a 13-room boutique hotel plus private home rentals. Reached by boat from Providenciales, situated near the world's third-largest barrier reef.
- 12
A six-suite private island off Nicaragua's Caribbean coast in the Pearl Cays, with overwater villas and beachfront accommodation. Maximum ten guests via whole-island booking, with 25+ staff members, helicopter transfers available.